He
says, "Eat food, not too much, mostly plants."
For a long time, scientists
have studied the world around us to provide answers for the common
man about things that affect us all. As the generations roll past,
the answers always seem to bring up new questions and new avenues of
study.
Particularly active fields
of study that most people find interesting because they affect our
daily lives are medicine, agriculture and human behaviour. A good
portion of us are also fascinated by astronomy and geology.
Scientific fields of study
are now as diverse as human interests and what is true in one place
may not hold true in another. This is certainly true in agriculture
where environment, culture and politics play a role in what can and
will happen to any given crop.
It is important to remember
that agriculture is related to, but not identical to the food
industry. "Excuse me," you say? Agriculture is the industry
that grows raw food products. The food industry takes what the
farmers produce and prepare it for sale and consumption.
It is a huge mistake to
think that Canadian agriculture is the same as the US agriculture.
Heck, we have different regulations between provinces and states
within both those countries. To quote California regulations on a
Canadian issue is dangerous because they are not the same. Nor is the
culture and political system.
The other thing to remember
is that every change that's taken place over the decades in
agriculture was an attempt to feed a growing population. Agriculture
exists to produce things people can eat. Also, agriculture still
seeks to use every part of what it produces whether that means as
food, fodder, fertilizer, fuel or medicine.
The food industry is a
marketing platform for value added agricultural products. It is
driven by consumer demand; which operates on emotion. The emotion
that works best on humans is fear; in particular, fear for our loved
ones. The food industry exploits this very well and, because food is
a basic necessity of life and the building blocks of our health, we
scare easily.
The food industry has
always dictated much of what the agriculture industry produces for
the simple fact that farmers need to make a living. So they grow what
the food industry pays top dollar to buy. The food industry delivers
to consumers the products they buy most. This is why consumers get a
say in what stores sell. (On a personal note, I will say that some
basic ingredients no longer make it to grocery store shelves because
not enough people buy them.)
I believe that the organic
agriculture industry started as a backlash to what some viewed as an
alarming move in food production to the use of chemicals to improve
crop yields and quality. This particular piece of agricultural
innovation grabbed center stage and all other aspects of agricultural
research seem to go unnoticed by the public. We talk about this at
Farming Smarter because, in fact, GMOs and chemicals are actually a
small part of growing a crop. They are tools. It's like asking to see
the screwdriver the carpenter used to build your house and deciding
on that one thing that the house is garbage.
This takes us back to the
scientists working hard to answer still troubling questions around
food security on earth. One of the things I heard Joe Schwarcz say
today is that organic farmers can spray a crop with Bacillus
thuringiensis; the bacterium that produces crystals protein (cry
proteins), which are toxic to many species of insects
(http://www.bt.ucsd.edu/what_is_bt.html ) because it is a naturally
sourced product. They mine it.
However, when scientists
use Bt protein in transgenic crops, people freak out. So if you don't
like the idea of the gene that promotes the production of Bt in your
corn, why are you okay with someone spraying Bt all over your corn
and calling it organic? I think that's a valid question.
A couple of decades ago, I
read On Food And Cooking: The Science and Lore of the Kitchen by
Harold McGee. In it I learned that the controversy (that was loud at
the time) around nitrates and nitrites in preserved meats was a
ridiculous furor over misinformation. It seems that some scientist
figured out that the reason saltpetre preserved foods was because it
contains nitrates and nitrites. Therefore, they figured out how to
isolate nitrates and nitrites from saltpetre and could then use these
preservatives much more judiciously and in much smaller quantities
than ever before. However, because most people did not know what they
were and some elements of the marketing community could use that to
their advantage, we had the uproar over nitrates and nitrites.
This is what we see in
modern controversy. Scientists find the active ingredient, find a way
to isolate it and use it in smaller amounts than ever before and
people freak out because they know what saltpetre is, but not
nitrates.
Marketing is a very tricky
industry. I've noticed “Gluten Free” on product labels now on
things that never had gluten in them. Or “natural” on products
that clearly are not. Anyone over 40 for sure can think of something
to add here. Marketers sell us stuff using fear, pride and envy or by
pulling our heart strings. But, marketing in the digital age is very
subtle and comes in the form of celebrity endorsements and
manufactured experts. Have you heard a about wasp nests in vaginas? I
mean you're smarter than that right?
Now, I'm not going to sit
here and tell you to just trust the scientists because even they will
tell you not to stop questioning everything. By gar, it's what drives
them to do what they do. I am going to suggest though that you also
question the information, the source, the credentials and the
motivations behind everything you hear.
We live in an increasingly
complex world and we are discovering increasingly complex things
about it daily. So, as Joe also said, life is full of risks and it
will never be completely safe ( I would add or easy to understand).
We make decisions every time we eat and the only way to live life
without taking some chances is to not live at all.
Remember that the science
will keep learning new things too. There will always be new things to
consider, new things that spark questions and technological advances
that sound scary to us because we don't understand. It is no longer
possible to understand everything around us.
Now more than ever,
we're making choices daily and hoping they are not going to harm us.
Cell phones, food, air, water, vaccines, and more ad nauseum. Our
modern society has much to understand and none of us can be an expert
in everything that touches our lives. We have to have trust and
faith.
That's not easy in a world
where humans have been known to do many things in the name of riches
that were decidedly NOT good for their fellow man. But if you find
yourself believing that every single person that works in agriculture
cares more about money than growing quality crops, you might want to
relax a little.
Regardless of the farming
method, if you eat unprocessed food, wash it and prepare it properly,
you can eat whatever you want. But if you're buying food you can just
microwave and eat, stop blaming the farmers for your health problems!